The most important stories can be uncomfortable

A turning point for senior editors was when McKenzie played back confidential, anonymised interviews with SAS whistleblowers. It was clear listening to their testimony that they had no time for “fog of war” arguments. We take the rules of combat incredibly seriously, they explained proudly, because to do otherwise would be a dereliction of duty. The whistleblowers were variously emotional, matter of fact, sad and angry, but they all made the same point: a few rogue soldiers had taken the law into their own hands.

Loading

McKenzie, a multiple Walkley Award winner, and Masters, the veteran investigative journalist, author and only member of the Australian media to be embedded with the SASR, slowly went about their work. They asked more questions, checked more facts and spoke to more people on the ground. By the time they had finished, McKenzie and Masters had interviewed dozens of witnesses and veterans over hundreds and hundreds of hours.

In some ways they went through a similar journey of understanding to the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, Paul Brereton, whose report found credible evidence 19 Australian special forces soldiers committed up to 39 murders of innocent Afghans.

“When what the inquiry has found is taken collectively, the answer to the question, ‘Is there substance to rumours of war crimes by elements of the Special Operations Task Group’ must sadly be, ‘Yes, there is’,” Justice Brereton said last week.

The Herald and The Age are similarly disappointed there turned out to be substance to the rumours. The alleged crimes “amount to a betrayal of all Australians who are rightly proud of the bravery and professionalism of the overwhelming majority of our armed forces”, The Age argued in an editorial published after the release of the report on Thursday. “Good men and women deployed in conflict zones are now in even greater danger due to the risk of retaliation. And the moral authority of an entire nation has been diminished.”

Loading

But we do not regret covering this issue. Public interest journalism is not a popularity contest and sometimes the most important stories are contentious and uncomfortable. Many of our readers were understandably ill at ease about our early coverage, including allegations Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith was among the soldiers alleged to have committed crimes. Our well-funded media rivals, Kerry Stokes’ Seven West Media and Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, muddied the waters rather than cover the story properly. We still face substantial legal action over the Roberts-Smith reporting.

We respect anyone’s right to criticise or question our journalism, particularly our subscribers who pay for our newsrooms. We aim to be mastheads that encourage a plurality of sensible views. And we do not seek to conflate the challenges we faced with the bravery of the SAS whistleblowers and families of Afgan families who risked far more to tell their stories. But over the course of the past three years we hope you believe we have made the case that investigating war crimes in Afghanistan was in the public interest – this is the key test after all.

Investigative journalism has always been at the heart of The Age. It is long, complicated and expensive work made more difficult by antiquated defamation, secrecy and freedom of information laws that run counter to proper standards of transparency and accountability. But we firmly believe it is worth it.

At Friday’s Walkley Awards, Kate McClymont and Jacqueline Maley were recognised for their investigation of allegations of sexual harassment involving former High Court Judge Dyson Heydon. Nick McKenzie, Joel Tozer and Sumeyya Ilanbey’s investigation (also involving 60 Minutes) into Victorian Labor branch stacking was also a winner. It has been our investigations that undercovered misconduct at casino group Crown Resorts, corruption at Casey Council in Melbourne’s south-east, gross failures at NSW hospitals, breakdowns in Victoria’s hotel quarantine system and the scandal that is NSW workplace insurer icare.

Each of these investigations represent significant investments in straitened times for most newsrooms that can take some time to have a real impact. Last week, Australia’s longest-running bribery investigation came to a head when a former senior executive from construction giant Leighton Holdings was arrested for alleged involvement in a $1 billion international graft scandal. The arrest came more than four years after McKenzie and Richard Baker broke the story in its Unaoil series. We think it was worth it. Hopefully you do too.

Thank you for your support. Without the contribution of subscribers our public interest journalism would not be possible.